Geppetto's Pizza & Ribs

I love the pizza here! It's super yummy and the people inside are always so friendly. I have a bunch of pizzerias in my town, yet I come here to get it sometimes! I have not been disappointed one time and I look forward to seeing this little place every time I come. Plus, who doesn't love a little Disney-inspired nostalgia?

The food is regularly fresh and delightful, workers gives awesome service. I love how neat it is and atmosphere. Keep up the good work.

Family owned and amazing.

This is the BEST Italian joint in all the neighboring towns! We ordered from here to change it up a few months ago, and we will not go anywhere else ever again. I highly suggest giving their Spaghetti (sub penne) and Vodka sauce! 😊 Their food all really taste home made, and that is hard to find these days. Great spot!!

My family is from west Milford's and we make the drive to wanaque because my kids love the pizza!!

So much character. The lady behind the counter has clearly been doing this for a long time. She loves the town and loves what she does. It's a family business and it's awesome. They have classic pizza parlor tables and lots of things on the walls that are part of local history. They have good specials and good hours as well. Obviously the most important thing is that the pizza is tasty. We greatly enjoyed our slices and laughed while reading the funny signs on the walls. There are a few parking spaces there and it's in a good location.

It's kind of an old school vintage kind a place but the pizza is way too good!

Looks like a place that has some history. When you walk in you instantly know they've been here a while. Haven't tried anything other than their pizza and it was pretty great, not the best but still very good.

My first time visiting this lovely little place. The staff are tremendous, food is delicious!Wonderful quaint atmosphere! My new regular pizza restaurant!

Love their food, great pizza, great subs. And betty is the nicest person in the world.

Best pizza in the area. Not too greasy, and a stone stove ensures that each slice will have a crispy bottom crust. Don't let looks deceive you- I heard that the building has been there for at least 30 years (and it's owned by the same people).Also, the pies are hand-made...which means you'll definitely want to call ahead of time.

The pizza crust here is a beautiful crunchy formula and the prices are unbeatable.

This place is so lovely and cozy. And the owner could not be any less nicer to her guests. She never forgets a face. I've been there multiple times, months in between and I've taken multiple friends who agree its the best pizza they've had in years. I highly recommend stopping in here after hiking nearby in Norvin Green or anywhere around Ringwood, NJ. They have a great 5$ deal for two slices and a soda. The pizza is great. The cheese is excellent and the marina sauce tastes amazing. The best part in the crust. Its soft and thick, but still very crunchy. I love it. Ignore the bad reviews on Yelp insulting this nice lady. I'm telling you, she is very friendly. Even towards my friend with a dairy and gluten allergy, she was very helpful in making her a custom dish from scratch. There is also lots of cool old signs inside from the 60s and even earlier. a great sight for curious souls

two days ago was the first time we went to this magnificent restaurant. But It is surely not the last time. We had great time with the efficient service, with the high quality dishes and booze and with the modest cost. We will absolutely go back there soon.

Hadn't stepped foot in here since 1981! It was our highschool lunch spot. The pizza was as good as I remember. crispy almost flaky crust and lots of cheese! It was the same woman behind the counter!! We had such a great walk down memory lane..this stop made my day 2 slices and a soda for $5 bucks even! Almost 1981 prices lol.Stop in and say hello! Great place great pizza

Very good for take out or delivery

Great! Chicken parm was good too.

The place is so cozy and the owner is kind and courteous. The pizza is a great balance of crust and toppings; one of the best slices I've ever had.

Very good service and the pizza looked delicious. Unlike other pizzerias their crust on the bottom is on the thicker side and more chewy than I expected. It was good pizza don't get me wrong, but it felt like I was biting into a hybrid Sicilian/plain slice. There is also not much parking there so when you go there hopefully they're not crowded otherwise you'll be parking across the street in another lot.